NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
The city of Charlotte is asking a judge to throw out a wrongful-death lawsuit filed by Iryna Zarutska’s family over security failures they say left her unprotected aboard the city’s light-rail system, arguing many of those decisions are protected by governmental immunity.
Zarutska’s murder drew national attention after surveillance video showed Decarlos Brown Jr. seated behind her aboard a Lynx Blue Line train before he is accused of stabbing her in the neck about four minutes after she boarded. The 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee had just left work at a local pizzeria.
Her family alleges Charlotte failed to adequately police and secure the light-rail system. The city now argues decisions involving transit policing, crime prevention, security contractors and public safety are government functions shielded from liability under North Carolina law.
PROSECUTORS SAY CHARLOTTE TRAIN STABBING CASE WON’T BE DISMISSED REGARDLESS OF COMPETENCY RULING
Charlotte’s new filing also acknowledges there was no private security guard inside Zarutska’s train car when she was killed, that Brown apparently boarded without presenting a ticket or pass and that the light-rail system operates without turnstiles or fare gates.

Iryna Zarutska curls up in fear as a man looms over her during a deadly attack on a Charlotte, N.C. light rail train. (NewsNation via Charlotte Area Transit System)
But the city denies those circumstances caused Zarutska’s death, arguing Brown acted on his own and that the attack could not have been predicted based on previous crime across the transit system.
DEATH OF GREAT-GRANDMOTHER BRUTALLY KILLED ON TRAIN TRIGGERS FEDERAL ACTION
Zarutska’s family sued Charlotte and its private transit security contractor, Professional Police Services, or PSS, in August, alleging security failures left riders vulnerable to violent crime.
Charlotte responded Monday with a 34-page filing asking a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge to throw out the claims against the city.
MURAL HONORING MURDERED UKRAINIAN REFUGEE IRYNA ZARUTSKA TAKEN DOWN IN PROVIDENCE AFTER LOCAL OUTRAGE
The city says the lawsuit challenges “law-enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight, and public-safety administration” and argues those activities are protected by governmental immunity.

A memorial dedicated to Iryna Zarutska in Charlotte, North Carolina on Sept. 11, 2025. (Peter Zay/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Zarutska’s family anticipated that defense in its lawsuit, arguing Charlotte waived immunity and that operating a light-rail system that charges fares amounts to a proprietary rather than governmental function.
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
The family’s complaint alleges stronger fare enforcement, physical barriers and adequate security could have prevented Brown from boarding the train or carrying out the attack.
It cites findings from the North Carolina state auditor showing Charlotte and the Charlotte Area Transit System (CATS) planned to spend about $2.23 million on safety and security equipment in 2025 but spent about $470,000, leaving roughly $1.76 million unspent and some planned security work unfinished.
TRUMP ADMINISTRATION LAUNCHES FEDERAL INVESTIGATION INTO ATLANTA’S MARTA SYSTEM AFTER FATAL TRAIN STABBING

Booking photo of Decarlos Dejuan Brown Jr., taken Sept. 14, 2022, following his arrest in Mecklenburg County. Brown is now charged in the Aug. 22, 2025, stabbing death of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska aboard a Charlotte light-rail train. (Mecklenburg County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO))
SIGN UP TO GET THE LATEST TRUE CRIME NEWS
Charlotte denies it ignored passenger safety, saying CATS maintained contracted armed and unarmed security, coordinated with law enforcement and undertook other public-safety initiatives before Zarutska’s death.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE FROM THE FOX TRUE CRIME HUB
The city also argues Brown’s failure to pay did not signal that he would attack Zarutska and says decisions about security staffing, where guards were placed, surveillance and fare enforcement did not cause her death.
FBI REPORTS LARGEST DROP IN VIOLENT CRIME AND MURDER SINCE 1937 AS HOMICIDES FALL MORE THAN 18%

Ukrainian Iryna Zarutska came to the U.S. to escape war but was stabbed to death in Charlotte. (Evgeniya Rush/GoFundMe)
SEND US A TIP
Instead, Charlotte argues Brown alone is responsible for Zarutska’s death.
LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST
If the judge allows any of the family’s claims against Charlotte to move forward, the city argues it should not have to pay Zarutska’s estate more than $1 million.
GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL
Charlotte is asking the judge to throw out all claims against the city and prevent the family from filing them again. The judge has not yet ruled.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
Fox News Digital reached out to the City of Charlotte, Professional Police Services and an attorney representing Zarutska’s estate for comment on the city’s motion to dismiss.
Fox News Digital’s Jasmine Baehr contributed to this report.
